Item: Corndog of Ugly Truths. Appears to be a normal corndog, but if anyone attempts to eat it, an unearthly voice will whisper unpleasant factoids about how the world works until its attacker puts it down and leaves it alone.

Item: Funny Horrible Shit Girl Halloween Beanie Full Face Winter Thermal 3 Hole Mask Neck-Long Head Cover; when not worn appears to be an ordinary beanie (albeit feces-colored), but when put on turns into this mask that causes -d12 on Charisma checks, smells like shit, and cannot be removed except by magical means

glumshoe:

glumshoe:

found a weird bottle with a skull and crossbones on it. can’t wait to drink this very cool Pirate Juice. 

the label’s worn down but I’m pretty sure the P stands for “pirate”

Item: Very Cool Pirate Juice; anyone who drinks it could get a cool peg-leg, hook-hand, or eyepatch! Roll d10:

1-6: temporarily causes a speech impediment in which the character over-emphasizes their rhotics for 2d4 hours

7: Neurological damage and gangrene causes a hand to wither and fall off

8: Neurological damage and gangrene causes a foot to wither and fall off

9: Scurvy

10: Permanently blind in one eye

Item: Cream Corn Pop Tarts; for half an hour grant the ability to vomit at will, this vomit then causing anyone that comes into physical contact with it to vomit as well, with their own vomit having the same effect, ad infinitum.